Foundationalism

This Element is an accessible introduction to controversies concerning the structure of knowledge and justification.

This Element is an introduction to controversies concerning the structure of knowledge and justification. It explains clearly the main arguments for foundationalism and the main objections to alternatives. It also develops and defends a specific form of foundationalism, one that allows a distinction between ideal and derivative justification.Foundationalism is a view about the structure of knowledge and justification. The heart of the thesis is the claim that if there is any knowledge or justified belief at all, then there is a kind of knowledge and justified belief that does not require inference from something else known or justifiably believed. This Element begins by exploring abstract arguments for foundationalism and against proposed alternatives. It then explores disagreements among foundationalists about how to understand foundational knowledge and justified belief, what is plausibly included in the foundations, and what is required for legitimate inference from foundations to the rest of what we believe. The author argues for the conclusion that one can combine insights captured by different versions of foundationalism by making a distinction between ideal justification and justification that falls short of that ideal.