Dialectics of Improvement

Dialectics of Improvement is a wonderfully insightful study of the interrelated currents of Enlightenment and Romanticism in Scottish literature. Covering commercial, religious, technological, aesthetic, moral, political, educational and scientific "improvement", it reveals how contested this concept was and how important it continues to be for our understanding of the period. * Angela Esterhammer, University of Toronto *
The judges were highly impressed by this book – it’s ambitious, admirably clear, and underpinned by meticulous research and close readings, covering both well-known canonical writers (Burns, Scott, Hogg) and less familiar writers/texts (Baillie, Galt). It’s impressively interdisciplinary: philosophy, historiography, textual criticism and editing history, print culture, politics and religion are all in the mix.This an excellent work of scholarship, insightful and enriched by many incisive and subtle readings of less familiar texts. -- Judging Panel * BARS First Book Prize 2021 *
Improvement permeated all levels of Scottish society, interconnected with myriad disciplines, and was a dominant concern of its literature. Dialectics of Improvement is a significant contribution to our understanding of the Romantic period and the extent to which that literature grappled with ideas of improvement. -- Ralph McLean * Burns Chronicle *
[...] with its meticulously researched case studies, and convincing argumentation, Dialectics of Improvement makes a valuable contribution to ongoing debates about the nature of Scottish Romanticism, the role of genre in the Romantic period, and the politics of the aesthetic. -- Catherine Jones, University of Aberdeen * Eighteenth-Century Scotland *
Gerard McKeever deconstructs the binary between Scotland’s modernizing Enlightenment and the vernacular cultures (Scots and Gaelic) [...] It is this “more openly unresolved, dialectically complex attitude” (24) that McKeever brings to bear on improvement that pushes it away from a stylized opposition to romance and into the much more conflicted territory of Romanticism. -- Alexander Dick, University of British Columbia * European Romantic Review *
Comprising attentive readings of texts astride different contexts, this humanely marshalled intellectual history provides firm foundations for a whole range of studies of Scottish Romanticism or other Romanticisms that might follow. -- Daniel Cook, University of Dundee * Scottish Literary Review *
McKeever's well-crafted and thoroughly researched monograph makes a clear case for the continued study of Scottish Romanticism and its relevance to our modern world. -- JoEllen DeLucia, Central Michigan University * The BARS Review *
Ideas of improvement underpin Enlightenment thought and Romantic reactions, and McKeever’s study skilfully offers nuanced readings of improvement that are attuned to historical, economic, and philosophical debates and innovations, and that draw attention to diverse literary genres. -- Amanda Blake Davis * The Year's Work in English Studies *